OUR BLOGS

Vinyl vs. Laminate Flooring: What’s Best for Your Home in 2025?

September 10, 2025 | Carpet Master Carpet One Floor & Home

Thinking about updating your floors but not sure whether vinyl or laminate is the right choice? You’re not alone. At Carpet Master Carpet One in Champaign, IL, we hear this question all the time—and we’re here to help clear things up.

As your neighborhood flooring experts, we’ve broken it down so you can feel confident in your choice. Let’s compare these two popular options and see which one fits your home and lifestyle best.

Durability: Which One Holds Up Better?

Vinyl Flooring:

Vinyl has come a long way in the last few years. Luxury vinyl planks (LVP) and tiles (LVT) are waterproof, scratch-resistant, and perfect for busy homes with kids or pets. Whether it’s muddy boots or a spilled juice box, vinyl takes it like a champ.

Laminate Flooring:

Laminate is known for its scratch resistance, making it a strong choice for high-traffic areas. However, traditional laminate isn’t always waterproof. New waterproof options are available—but be sure to check the specs.

🏆 Winner: Vinyl—especially if water resistance is a priority.

Want to learn more about Vinyl Flooring? Check out our Luxury Vinyl Guide.

Style & Appearance: Which Looks Better?

Vinyl:

Today’s vinyl mimics the look of real hardwood and stone so well, many folks can’t tell the difference. With textured finishes and a wide range of colors, you’ll find styles that match modern, rustic, or traditional decor.

Laminate:

Laminate also offers realistic wood and tile visuals. It tends to feel more rigid and solid underfoot, which some homeowners prefer.

🏆 Winner: Tie—both offer stunning, realistic visuals. It really comes down to your personal style.

Comfort & Feel: What’s It Like Underfoot?

Vinyl:

Softer and warmer than tile, vinyl is comfortable to walk on and works great with radiant heat systems.

Laminate:

It’s firmer and often louder underfoot. Underlayment can help reduce noise and add a bit of cushion.

🏆 Winner: Vinyl, especially if comfort is a top priority.

Installation & Budget: What to Expect

Vinyl Flooring:

Easy to install with click-lock or peel-and-stick options. It’s generally more budget-friendly than hardwood and requires less prep work.

Laminate Flooring:

Laminate is also a DIY favorite, but it may require more subfloor prep. Pricing is similar, but vinyl can sometimes come in slightly lower depending on the style.

🏆 Winner: Vinyl, for flexibility and overall value.

Best Rooms for Each

• Vinyl Flooring: Kitchens, bathrooms, basements, mudrooms—anywhere moisture is an issue.
• Laminate Flooring: Living rooms, bedrooms, hallways—areas where you want durability without worrying about water.

Curious what it would look like on your floors? Check out Room Visualizer.

Still Not Sure? Let Us Help.

We get it—there are a lot of great options out there. That’s why Carpet Master Carpet One offers free flooring estimates, in-home consultations, and expert guidance. Plus, with our Room by Room displays, you can compare styles, colors, and warranties side-by-side without the overwhelm.

And hey—if you’re still torn, we’ll even let you take home samples so you can see what looks best in your own light.

Come Talk Flooring With Your Neighbors

We’re not just a flooring store—we’re your neighbors here in Champaign. Stop by, call us, or book an appointment. We’ll help you find the right floor for your home, your life, and your budget.

🛠️ Need a little more help deciding? Ask us about our waterproof flooring, pet-friendly options, and our 110% Price Match Guarantee.